The Dreaded RFP Process Otherwise Known As "who's The Best Guesser In Town?"
Posted on Sunday, 17th January 2010 - 5:50 pm by Fay Kelly
Every month you hope those RFP`s come through the
letterbox and when they do you groan. The briefing document is
so basic that you might as well make it up as you go along.
What? Oh, I see, that`s exactly what you do? RFP`s - requests
for proposals, ITTs - invitations to tender, words that can
strike dread in the hearts of the toughest biz dev executives.
Wouldn`t it be great if we could say "sorry, we don`t
respond to RFP`s, especially blind ones where we can`t even get
to talk to a human being."
Actually, quite a few of my clients say precisely
that and they`re still in business and still thriving.
The thing that puzzles me, is why on earth would
the purchasing clients go looking for a supplier with whom they
are going to invest considerable resource, based on such a flawed
system? It`s like saying "Hello, we`ve got a ton of money
and we`re going to give it to the best guesser in
My clients in marcoms say, "in a real world
Fay we can`t say no to RFP`s, we can`t say no to beauty parades,
we can`t say no to pitches - we`d have no business if we
Fair enough, I`m not trying to change the world in
a day. I work with what I have and over the years we`ve come up
with some really neat ways to overcome the major obstacles of
responding to a blind RFP. My first option is always to
encourage my client to walk away from it unless they are
convinced (and can prove) they stand an 85%+ chance of success.
Otherwise it`s a great way to drive up your cost of sale and
provide "free consulting".
Anyway, here`s a little tip I`ve picked up and
you`d be amazed at how often it has paid off - even in this
advanced age of computer literacy.
With blind RFP`s you usually have to submit your
questions in writing in a template provided, usually a word doc,
and the questions, along with the answers, are circulated to all
competing suppliers. Since the job of co-ordinating this is
usually delegated to someone in purchasing, they simply cut and
paste from the template they receive and circulate that. If you
click on File, then on properties, you can often find who
generated the original document and get an idea of the
competition you face. This means of course, you should never
send out a confidential document like this without
"doctoring" the properties so no-one can trace it back
to you if your questions are circulated.
Back to blind RFP`s - if you do decide to
participate, and you`re allowed to put your questions in writing,
even if they and the answers are circulated, it makes sense to
get as much information as you can in order to populate your
storyboard. Clients often say "but what`s the point of that
if everyone gets to see the answers to our questions?" My
response is, "what good are the answers to everyone if they
didn`t ask the question in the first place and consequently,
don`t understand the point of the question?" This is borne
out by experience.
So, still on the subject of questions - which are
the most important ones to ask, i.e. what information do you need
to enable you to win the contract and why do you need that
information and how will you use it to populate your storyboard?
That`s what I teach my clients and even if other
people see those questions and answers in writing, they don`t
know how to use the information to their advantage so my clients
always have the edge.
A quick footnote. I talk about the
"storyboard" a few times in my blog and other articles
on the net, and people who haven`t worked with me have written to
ask me about it so I`m putting a short video together to
introduce the storyboard concept. Keep checking the website.
You`ll be able to download it free once it`s up there. I don`t
guarantee a Hollywood production but the content is hugely
Email - Permalink